LATEST
Papa León XIV enfrenta su primera crisis: la FSSPX amenaza con ordenar obispos sin autorización Proposal to Eliminate Winter Recess for Lawmakers in Mendoza Argentine Court Strikes Down Milei's Citizenship Decree as Unconstitutional Miraculous Rescue: 3-Year-Old Boy Found Alive After 6 Days Under Rubble in Venezuela Keiko Fujimori Elected President of Peru in Historic Election ANSES Confirms 2.15% Increase for July: Minimum Pension with Bonus Reaches $481,989 Mbappé Shines with Brace as France Thrashes Sweden 3-0 to Reach World Cup 2026 Round of 16 Murió Daniel Melingo, figura emblemática del rock y el tango, a los 68 años NASA Races Against Time to Rescue Swift Telescope Before It Falls to Earth Wall Street Hits Historic Record as Argentine Assets Lead Market Gains Papa León XIV enfrenta su primera crisis: la FSSPX amenaza con ordenar obispos sin autorización Proposal to Eliminate Winter Recess for Lawmakers in Mendoza Argentine Court Strikes Down Milei's Citizenship Decree as Unconstitutional Miraculous Rescue: 3-Year-Old Boy Found Alive After 6 Days Under Rubble in Venezuela Keiko Fujimori Elected President of Peru in Historic Election ANSES Confirms 2.15% Increase for July: Minimum Pension with Bonus Reaches $481,989 Mbappé Shines with Brace as France Thrashes Sweden 3-0 to Reach World Cup 2026 Round of 16 Murió Daniel Melingo, figura emblemática del rock y el tango, a los 68 años NASA Races Against Time to Rescue Swift Telescope Before It Falls to Earth Wall Street Hits Historic Record as Argentine Assets Lead Market Gains
Español English 中文 Português Français Italiano Deutsch العربية Русский اردو

Argentine Court Strikes Down Milei's Citizenship Decree as Unconstitutional

30/06/2026 21:29 - Politica

A Ruling That Upholds Constitutional Boundaries

The National Electoral Chamber (Cámara Nacional Electoral) has annulled Decree 366/2025, issued by President Javier Milei, which aimed to transfer the authority to grant Argentine citizenship to the National Directorate of Migrations. This power has historically been held by federal judges specializing in electoral matters.

The tribunal, composed of judges Santiago Corcuera, Alberto Dalla Via, and Daniel Bejas, reached this decision while resolving the case of Liping Yang, a Chinese citizen whose citizenship application had been rejected by the federal electoral judge of Entre Ríos province.

Why Was It Declared Unconstitutional?

  • Prohibited electoral matter: Article 99, section 3 of the Argentine Constitution explicitly forbids issuing DNUs (Decrees of Necessity and Urgency) on electoral matters, under penalty of absolute and irremediable nullity.
  • Political rights at stake: Granting citizenship is directly linked to the exercise of political rights—it's not merely an immigration administrative issue.
  • No proven urgency: The Executive Branch failed to demonstrate exceptional circumstances justifying the bypass of legislative procedure.

What Did the Decree Establish?

The decree sought to make the National Directorate of Migrations the agency responsible for verifying eligibility for citizenship. The Executive argued it was "unreasonable" for this process to remain under judicial oversight, but the Chamber determined these arguments responded to criteria of administrative convenience rather than constitutional emergency.

The Court's Reasoning

"By modifying the authority of courts to decide on the granting or denial of Argentine citizenship, it alters the regime established by the legislature for the acquisition of political rights", the judges stated in one of the ruling's central passages.

The tribunal recalled that Article 76 of the Constitution prohibits legislative delegation outside of cases expressly authorized by the Constitution itself, and that electoral norms occupy a specially protected place because they regulate the expression of popular will.

Consequences of the Ruling

Measure Ordered Recipient
Annulment of the DNU regarding citizenship All courts nationwide
Revocation of Liping Yang's rejection Federal Court of Entre Ríos
Official communication National Ministry of Security
Notification to all federal electoral judges Entire country

The Chamber ordered that Liping Yang's case continue under the regime established by Law 346 and its regulatory decree, which assign competence to federal judges. It also noted this was the first opportunity to rule on the validity of Decree 366/2025.

What is a DNU?

Decrees of Necessity and Urgency are tools the Argentine Constitution grants the Executive Branch to legislate exceptionally when Congress cannot act. However, they have express limits: they cannot be used for electoral, tax, criminal, or procedural matters, nor to alter citizens' political rights. This safeguard prevents executive overreach in sensitive democratic areas.

Source: Infobae

Today's News
Alfredo's Column Alfredo S. Quiroga

Alfredo S. Quiroga